Is Your Roofing Quote Fair? What State College Homeowners Need to Know.
What Should You Be Paying for a New State College Roof?

Getting a quote for a new roof or significant repairs on your State College home can feel like navigating a maze. You're likely getting multiple estimates, and the numbers can vary quite a bit. It's natural to wonder: how do you know if you're getting a fair price? What factors influence the cost of a roofing project in areas like Bellefonte, Boalsburg, or even further out in Mill Hall? At Stoltzfus Bros Construction, we believe in transparency and want to empower homeowners across Central Pennsylvania to understand what goes into a roofing quote so they can make informed decisions.
It's tempting to simply go with the lowest bid, but that can sometimes lead to cutting corners on materials or workmanship, which can cost you more in the long run. Conversely, the highest bid isn't always the best. A fair roofing quote should be detailed, transparent, and reflect the quality of materials and the expertise of the contractor. So, how do you decipher the numbers and ensure you're getting a fair deal for your roofing needs in communities like State College, Bellefonte, Spring Mills or Lemont?
Here are some key factors that influence a roofing quote and what you should look for to determine its fairness:
1. Scope of Work (The Details Matter): A reputable roofing contractor, like Stoltzfus Bros Construction, will provide a detailed breakdown of the work to be done. This should include:
- Material Specifications: What type and brand of shingles are being used? For asphalt roofs, is it a quality brand like Owens Corning? What about underlayment, flashing, and other necessary components? A quote that simply says "shingles" isn't detailed enough. You want to know the specific product and its warranty.
- Removal of Old Roofing: Is the cost of removing and disposing of your old roofing included? This can be a significant part of the job and should be clearly stated.
- Installation Procedures: What steps will the contractor take during installation? This should include details about ventilation, securing underlayment, and proper shingle application.
- Flashing Details: How will flashing around chimneys, vents, and other penetrations be handled? Proper flashing is crucial for preventing leaks.
- Cleanup: Will the contractor be responsible for cleaning up debris after the job is complete?
A vague quote without these details should raise a red flag. A fair quote from Stoltzfus Bros Construction will clearly outline the scope of work.
2. Material Costs (Quality Comes at a Price): The cost of roofing materials can vary significantly depending on the type and quality. Asphalt shingles come in different grades with varying lifespans and warranties. A quote using high-quality, durable shingles from a reputable manufacturer like Owens Corning will naturally be higher than one using lower-grade materials. It's important to compare "apples to apples" when evaluating quotes. Ask about the quality and warranty of the materials being proposed.
3. Labor Costs (Experience and Expertise): Roofing is skilled labor. An experienced and reputable contractor like Stoltzfus Bros Construction will have labor costs that reflect their expertise, insurance, and overhead. Be wary of quotes that seem unusually low, as this might indicate inexperienced or uninsured workers, which can lead to problems down the line.
4. Overhead and Profit (A Necessary Part of Doing Business): A fair quote will include the contractor's overhead costs (insurance, licenses, etc.) and a reasonable profit margin. This is essential for the contractor to stay in business, provide quality service, and stand behind their work.
5. Warranty (Protecting Your Investment): A good roofing contractor will offer a warranty on their workmanship, in addition to any manufacturer warranties on the materials. Understand the terms of the warranty and what it covers. Stoltzfus Bros Construction stands behind our work and will clearly outline our warranty.
Questions to Ask to Ensure a Fair Quote:
- Can you provide a detailed breakdown of the materials and labor costs?
- What is the brand and grade of the shingles you will be using? What is the manufacturer's warranty?
- Are you insured and licensed? Can you provide proof?
- What is your company's workmanship warranty?
- What is your process for cleanup and disposal of old materials?
- Do you anticipate any potential additional costs? If so, under what circumstances?
By asking these questions and carefully reviewing the details of each quote, you can better assess whether you're getting a fair price for your roofing project in State College, Bellefonte, Boalsburg, Mill Hall, Spring Mills, Lemont, or any of the surrounding areas.
Remember, the cheapest quote isn't always the best value. Investing in quality materials and experienced professionals like Stoltzfus Bros Construction ensures a durable and long-lasting roof that will protect your home for years to come. If you're in Central Pennsylvania and are looking for a fair and transparent roofing quote, we encourage you to Contact us at Stoltzfus Bros Construction. We're committed to providing quality work at a fair price.
Our Reliable and Efficient Team is Ready To Help.
Recent Posts
